Noel Tata at odds with more fellow trustees


Noel Tata at odds with more fellow trustees
Within the trusts, Noel has found himself in conflict with fellow trustees on various governance issues.

MUMBAI: Two years after taking over stewardship of the Tata charitable trusts following Ratan Tata‘s death, Noel Tata may be losing support within the group’s key decision-making bodies.Opposition to his views has been building on two fronts: at Tata Sons, where he’s become a lone voice on the board, and within Tata Trusts, which control the holding company and wield decisive influence over the future of the sprawling conglomerate. Within the trusts, Noel has found himself in conflict with fellow trustees on various governance issues.Noel’s position within the trusts appears less acceptable, with Jimmy Tata, his 86-year-old half-brother and a fellow trustee, backing the listing of Tata Sons and criticising what he described as the growing concentration of influence in the trusts through induction of multiple members of Noel Tata’s family. By warning against a “back-door takeover” of Tata Sons, Jimmy has effectively aligned himself against the 70-year-old Noel on one of the most contentious issues facing the group, which is the listing, thus prompting some industry observers to characterise the tensions as “Tata versus Tata”.Jimmy’s intervention has also drawn attention to Jehangir HC Jehangir, a senior trustee with whom he shares a close association. Having moved to Pune from Mumbai several years ago, Jimmy routinely undergoes medical check-ups at the city’s Jehangir Hospital, founded by the Jehangir family. Jehangir remains the only major trustee who has not publicly articulated a position on either the proposed listing of Tata Sons or the extension of chairman N Chandrasekaran’s tenure for a third term.Jehangir, however, has not shied away from contentious governance matters. He backed the removal of fellow trustee Vijay Singh from the Tata Sons board. Along with trustee Venu Srinivasan, Singh had raised concerns over the induction of Neville Tata, Noel’s son, into the trusts without a wider process of consultation among trustees.Another prominent voice in the dispute is Mehli Mistry, a trustee and confidant of the late Ratan Tata, who shares longstanding ties with Jimmy. Mistry has challenged his removal from the Sir Dorabji Tata Trust and Sir Ratan Tata Trust before the Charity Commissioner. Taken together, the developments point to a narrowing of support for Noel within the trusts. Apart from Neville and Bhaskar Bhat, both recent additions to the trusts, existing trustees have either questioned aspects of Noel’s approach or aligned with competing views or chosen to remain publicly silent.The same pattern was visible at Tata Sons. Noel’s reservations over listing the holding company and extending Chandrasekaran’s tenure found little support among fellow directors.For a leader once seen as the natural custodian of the Tata legacy after Ratan Tata, the challenge is no longer one of succession but influence.



Source link

Exit mobile version