Tenant tells landlady to run her tailoring business from home instead of evicting, but Delhi High Court upholds landlady’s plea and orders eviction saying tenant cannot dictate her choice


Tenant tells landlady to run her tailoring business from home instead of evicting, but Delhi High Court upholds landlady's plea and orders eviction saying tenant cannot dictate her choice
She had been operating her ladies’ tailoring business from her residence for a considerable period. (Image for representative purpose only)

Tenant-landlord cases can be very tricky and eviction often requires court intervention. In one such case in Delhi, a landlady had to take her fight to evict a tenant to the Delhi High Court to regain possession of a shop where she wanted to expand her business.The Delhi High Court recently ruled in favour of the landlady and upheld the eviction order against the tenant. Read on to know what happened:

What the case is about

The case involved a woman who owned a property consisting of four ground-floor shops and accommodation on the upper floors.She had been operating her ladies’ tailoring business from her residence for a considerable period. As the business expanded, she needed more space and asked her tenant to vacate the premises and find alternative accommodation.However, the tenant declined to leave. Instead, she asked the woman to continue running her tailoring business from home and allow her to retain the property, arguing that her livelihood depended entirely on it and that finding a comparable property in the same locality was not possible at that time.The landlady subsequently filed an eviction petition in 2019. The Additional Rent Controller rejected the tenant’s application seeking permission to contest the eviction proceedings and ordered eviction in 2024. The tenants challenged this decision before the Delhi High Court, but their revision petition was dismissed on November 6, 2026, with the court upholding the eviction order.

Why Delhi High Court ruled in favour of landlady

The tenants argued that the landlady was already doing tailoring work from her residence and had access to other properties that could meet her requirements.They also questioned whether her stated need for the shop was genuine, particularly because she had pursued eviction proceedings earlier for a different requirement.During the proceedings, the tenant’s lawyer argued that the landlady had offered no reason beyond her desire to operate her ladies’ tailoring business from the premises and her preference for a location on the main road.The landlady’s lawyer countered that the tenant could not dictate the manner or location in which the landlady should conduct her tailoring business. He argued that the landlady was the best judge of her own requirements.The Delhi High Court observed that the landlady’s ability to conduct tailoring work from home did not automatically mean that the residential property was reasonably suitable for the commercial purpose for which she now sought the shop.The court also dismissed the contention that her requirement was not genuine because her son was already running a business from another shop in the same property. It held that his business operations did not, by themselves, make her own demand for the tenanted premises fictitious.Rejecting the challenge to the landlady’s stated need, the court observed: “The Petitioners’ reliance on the earlier proceedings and on the existing tailoring activity, without more, does not disclose a triable issue as to the genuineness of the requirement pleaded in the present petition.”The court then examined the claim that other properties could serve as alternative accommodation.The landlady maintained that some of these shops had been sold in October 2009, while another ground-floor property was occupied by a tenant. She also disputed the suitability of the upper-floor accommodation for the business she proposed to run.The High Court found that property-tax receipts alone did not establish present ownership or availability. The tenants had not produced sufficient material to demonstrate that the properties were vacant, accessible and reasonably suitable for the proposed tailoring business. Other portions of the larger property were either being used for storage or occupied by existing businesses, while some accommodation was in a dilapidated condition.The court summarised its conclusion on alternative accommodation as follows: “The Petitioners have, therefore, failed to raise a triable issue with respect to the availability of reasonably suitable alternative accommodation.”Advocate Amitraj Kaushal, who practises at the Supreme Court of India, told ET that the landlady prevailed because she established a genuine requirement for the shop to operate her tailoring business and earn her livelihood.According to Kaushal, the Delhi High Court reiterated that a landlady is the best judge of her own requirements and that a tenant cannot dictate how she should use her property.The fact that the landlady was already running her ladies’ tailoring business from her residence did not negate her need for a dedicated commercial shop to carry on the same activity.



Source link

Exit mobile version